Georgia Criminal Defense Lawyers

Georgia criminal defense lawyers fight criminal offenses in all GA courts.

Free Consultation

(888) 205-9314

  • Home
  • Sentencing & Penalties
  • Criminal Court Procedures
  • About Us
    • Disclaimer Privacy Policy
  • Blog

Minor Marijuana Offenses: Deportation No Longer Automatic for Some

May 6, 2013

 According to a new U. S. Supreme Court ruling, some legal residents arrested for possessing minor amounts of marijuana may no longer have to fear automatic deportation. This case was based upon a Georgia man who had come to America from Jamaica with his family back in 1984 when he was only three years old. Since that time, Adrian Moncrieffe got a job, married and had children.

Basic Facts of This Case

Unfortunately, Mr. Moncrieffe was arrested in 2007 for having 1.3 grams of marijuana (one-twentieth of an ounce) in his possession. What proved to be his major undoing was the Georgia statute governing punishment for marijuana possession. In a nutshell, “It doesn’t differentiate between his crime and more serious offenses.”

marijuana jointBased upon a report written by a U. S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) officer, “Moncrieffe was charged under Georgia law with possession with intent to distribute . . .” This statute has been applied to others like Moncrieffe who just had the equivalent of a $30 bag of weed on him when he was pulled over by Georgia law officers — as well as those clearly planning to “distribute up to 10 pounds of illicit narcotics.”

Although Moncrieffe had no prior criminal record, his lawyer failed to tell him that if he accepted the plea deal, he could face deportation. The defendant was apparently attracted to the plea because it would allow him to avoid prison and later have his conviction “expunged after five years of satisfactory probation.” (Since these events unfolded, the U. S. Supreme Court now requires lawyers to inform their clients about all deportation possibilities.)

How the Lower Court Initially Handled This Case

Once the defendant accepted his plea deal, he was jailed and deported to Jamaica. The federal government basically held that in regards to sentencing, “there was no discretion on the matter because Moncrieffe had been convicted of an aggravated felony.” Upon deportation, Moncrieffe was separated from his wife and five children.

What the U. S. Supreme Court Recently Held

What the uniquely disciplined yet compassionate Justice Sonia Sotomayor said in her opinion – which represents the views of six other justices – was clear and unequivocal. She said that since the amount of marijuana in this case was so small and involved no sale, Moncrieffe’s crime did “not qualify as an aggravated felony.” She also clearly stated that to hold otherwise “defies the common sense conception of these terms.”  Interestingly enough, only Justices Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito dissented from her majority opinion.

Moncrieffe’s Future Looks Much Brighter Now

As a result of this decision, Moncrieffe is expected to petition immigration authorities for the right to return to America and his family. According to an article by NPR reporter Nina Tottenberg, “Most experts say he has an excellent chance of succeeding . . .” It’s believed his conviction under Georgia law has now been expunged from the record.

Decision May Favorably Impact Others Facing Deportation

ABC reporter Ted Hesson has said in one of his most recent articles that while this ruling “won’t bring about a major change in the immigration system . . . it could affect the outcome in hundreds of similar cases each year.” Hesson also pointed out the following key part of Justice Soto Mayor’s majority opinion that’s been quoted in The New York Times. “Sharing a small amount of marijuana for no remuneration, let alone possession with intent to do so, does not fit easily into the everyday understanding of trafficking, which ordinarily means some sort of commercial dealing.”

 

By Elizabeth Smith

 

Filed Under: drug charges Tagged With: drugs, immigration

Free Consultation

Contact our attorneys for a free legal case evaluation on any criminal charge by calling:


(888) 205-9314


Receive our free legal defense consultation and case evaluation. We'll explain what you are facing in plain language, and tell you how we can help.

Georgia Criminal Charges

  • Assault and Battery
  • Burglary
  • Criminal Damage – Trespassing
  • Criminal Traffic Offenses
  • Disorderly Conduct
  • Domestic Violence
  • Drug Possession
  • Drug Possession – Cocaine
  • Drug Possession – Heroin
  • Drug Possession – Marijuana
  • Drug Possession – Methamphetamine
  • DUI – First Offense
  • DUI – Second/Third Offense
  • Drug Possession – Intent to Distribute / Drug Trafficking
  • Failure To Appear
  • Fraud
  • Hit and Run
  • Restraining Order Violations
  • Robbery
  • Stalking
  • Suspended License
  • Theft – Shoplifting
  • Weapons Charges
Copyright © 2023 Get Lawyer Leads, Inc.
THIS IS AN ADVERTISEMENT. This is not a law firm or referral service and does not provide legal advice. This is a free matching service only, claim reviews will be performed by a third party attorney. An attorney-client relationship is not formed when you submit the form and you are under no obligation to retain a lawyer who contacts you through this service. Services are not available in all states.